CALEx pilots are now departing on a trip that will determine our pay and working conditions for many years to come. CONTRACT �02 will also play a role in shaping other airline pilot contracts in the same way that their achievements help us. Just like the trips we fly every day, it helps to have a picture of the route ahead before we depart.
This article will describe briefly the interrelated aspects of negotiations and contract enforcement under the Railway Labor Act. Managing these complex processes well is the job of pilot leaders and professional staff. Learning about the process and supporting your elected pilot leaders and Negotiating Committee is up to the pilot group as a whole.
Effective Negotiations Under the RLA
Negotiations in the airline business are conducted under the Railway Labor Act (RLA), not the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA). Under the RLA, the negotiating process is overseen by the National Mediation Board (NMB), not the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB). This is one example of the unique features of the RLA that must be factored into how we handle CONTRACT �02 negotiations.
RLA-conducted negotiations can be broken down into components so that necessary resources can be organized and applied to each part. The effective marshalling and application of these resources often determines whether the outcome is successful. Following is an outline of RLA negotiations.
- Pre-Section 6 Period � Contracts under the RLA don�t technically �expire.� Instead, they become �amendable.� The notice sent by either party that wants to amend the contract is called a �Section 6 Notice,� pursuant to the part of the RLA that provides for reopening the contract. It is usually sent 30�60 days prior to the amendable date of the contract. However, preparation for negotiations takes place long before the Section 6 Notice is sent.
Your Negotiating Committee expects to engage in direct bargaining starting at the end of 2001 � at approximately the same time as mainline negotiations.
Intense preparation characterizes the pre-Section 6 period and often is taking place 12�18 months prior to the start of contract talks. You�ve seen this preparation in the form of our questionnaire to the pilot group asking for your input and direction; telephone surveys seeking pilot group goals and objectives; building of the STARTeam structure and membership; and the development of communication structures and materials, such as this newsletter, to educate and inform the pilot group. Work is also going on behind the scenes to perform an economic and financial analysis of the company and industry; compare the CALEx contract with those of other similar airlines; and coordinate your negotiations with those at the mainline.
There is no specific time period required for direct negotiations. Depending on the number of issues and management�s desire to reach an agreement, negotiations can last for a substantial amount of time. During direct negotiations, the parties try to bargain using one of two methods of bargaining:
- 1) Traditional � A method of bargaining in which proposals detailing each party�s wants and needs in particular contract sections are exchanged.
- 2) �Interest-based bargaining� (IBB) � A method of bargaining that focuses more on mutual problem solving. (An explanation of IBB and the differences between it and traditional bargaining will be included in later issues of From the Table).
One, two, or three negotiating sessions a month between our pilot group and the Company can normally be expected. Regular updates on the status of talks will be provided to the pilot group while negotiations are underway.
Much strategy and discussion goes into the selection of subjects for bargaining at each session. Also, the Negotiating Committee must draw on outside expertise and resources pertaining to each contract area � e.g. economic and financial analysis, retirement and insurance, scheduling, and scope to ensure that the best provisions are negotiated into each portion of the agreement. A sizable communication effort will be required to keep the pilot group informed, unified, and active in the negotiation process. Also, the negotiators will usually try to write contract language for tentatively agreed provisions while the negotiation is ongoing.
- Mediation, Super-mediation and the Proffer of Arbitration � The NMB is made up of three Board members appointed by the President of the United States. There is also a staff of mediators within the organization. If talks aren�t progressing satisfactorily, either party, or both, may request the NMB�s help by assigning a staff mediator to sit with the parties. A mediator has no power to decide things or force the parties to reach agreement. He or she tries skillfully to bridge gaps between the parties� positions. Sometimes one of the three Board members will join the talks. This is commonly known as super-mediation. It can take place before or after the parties are released from negotiations by the NMB. When the NMB determines that further mediation will not be productive, the RLA requires that the parties be offered binding arbitration by a neutral third party. Neither party is required to accept this offer and both must accept for it to take place. If the offer takes place, that neutral party will decide remaining issues in negotiations.
During mediation, the rules governing direct negotiations remain applicable. That is, the parties are prohibited from taking self-help actions to force an agreement.
Mediation and super-mediation are more the norm than the exception in airline labor negotiations these days. Currently, Delta, Comair, and Air Wisconsin, to name just a few, are in contract talks involving a mediator and/or a member of the NMB. It is very unusual for either the Company or the union to accept the NMB�s final offer of binding arbitration.
Perhaps more so than in any other period, pilot group resources and professional staff are called upon during mediation to prepare for the possibility that there won�t be a negotiated agreement prior to self-help measures. In addition to continuing negotiations, computer and instant communication systems must be tested, contingency plans must be put in place, and other strike preparedness actions taken.
It�s typical for the NMB to continue efforts to resolve disputes during the cooling-off period. Many times this help, along with the looming deadline, leads to a new contract. If it doesn�t, at the conclusion of the cooling-off period, the union can engage in work stoppages, boycotts, and other actions. On the other hand, the company can impose its last contract offer, lock employees out of the workplace, or hire replacement pilots, if strike-bound, in an effort to continue operations.
During the 30-day period that a PEB is working and for another 30-day cooling-off period thereafter, the parties are again prohibited from engaging in self-help measures. In addition to a PEB, Congress retains the power to pass legislation to resolve disputes, create additional emergency boards, require binding arbitration, or impose the PEB report as law.
The PEB has been used only occasionally in the airline industry � most recently to resolve a dispute between American Airlines and its pilots in 1997. Although Congressional intervention is not favored, it has occurred in the railroad industry. These approaches are highly dependent upon current political circumstances and dynamics.
The RLA negotiating process can be complex and lengthy. Applying pilot and professional resources throughout the process, and managing those resources at each stage, is a substantial undertaking. Success comes from learning the process and helping your pilot leaders execute strategy successfully during the negotiating process.
To facilitate pilot involvement, the IACP has enacted the STARTeam program. This is a program to keep all pilots informed and involved. The Negotiating Committee wants all Continental Express pilots to have a small part in the outcome of Contract 2002. When the pilot group and the Negotiating Committee work together as a team, the true success of contract bargaining can be achieved under the RLA.
|
Effective Negotiations + Contract Enforcement = Bargaining Power |